Lead Generation · Daily Q&A #13

Are Angi, HomeAdvisor, or Thumbtack worth it for contractors?

Direct answer: They're a bridge, not a business. Shared-lead platforms sell the same lead to 4-5 contractors at once for $15-100 a pop, so you're in a speed-and-price war before you've even called back — and the lead is gone the second someone cheaper answers first. They make sense in two narrow cases: you have open truck capacity you need to fill this week, or you're new to a market with zero reputation. Otherwise they're a tax you pay until your owned channels (Google Business Profile, reviews, video) carry you. Plan the exit: shift 20% of that spend to owned channels monthly and you're off shared leads in about 90 days.

The full breakdown

  • The core math: that lead is sold to 4-5 other contractors — you compete on speed and price from the first call, and you own nothing once the job is done
  • Real price range: roughly $15-100 per shared lead depending on trade and market; emergency terms cost the most and close best, so that's where your money goes first
  • Refund policies have tightened — 'charged for a no-show?' credit requests are harder to win, and you still ate the call time
  • The two cases where they DO work: excess capacity you must fill this week, and a brand-new market with no Google reviews yet — treat both as temporary crutches
  • The exit path: redirect ~20% of spend to owned channels each month — GBP posts, review requests, daily video — so in ~90 days shared leads become the spare tire, not the engine
  • Owned channels compound: a video keeps working for months and a review keeps converting for years — a shared lead converts once and is gone forever

Want this done for your business?

Get the free growth audit — we'll run the numbers on what your market's leads are really costing you: start here.

Get the free growth audit →

Related questions

Published 2026-10-04 · Part of the BizLift Q&A knowledge base · Related: plans & pricing, blog, services